Guidelines

 

Home Major Projects Guidelines

Social Justice Guidelines

For the Social Justice Committee of the Unitarian Universalist Fellowship of Fredericksburg  

Adopted Summer 2006 by Social Justice Committee.  Advisory only for UUFF Board

 

 TABLE OF CONTENTS

I.  Background and introduction

A.  Scope

B.  Purpose and vision

II.  Impromptu Activities

A.  Scope and purpose

B.  Finding members with similar social issue interests

C.  Responsibility of the Social Justice Committee (SJC) when an individual or informal          group wants to produce an educational event:  None

III.  Priority Projects

A.  Purpose of this process

 

B.  What are “Priority” and Interim Projects, and reasons to have them

1.  Priority Project defined  

2.  Interim Project defined

C.  Project Selection

1.  Ways to initiate a Project Proposal  

2.  Steps for handling written proposals to the SJC

3.  General criteria to apply to the proposal  

4.  Possible Committee determinations or outcomes

5.  Conducting a general membership interest survey

D.  Guidelines for  Research and Education

          1.  Purpose

2..  How much research and education are required for a topic?

3..  What are the SJC’s general research standards?

4.  What educational methodologies will be used?

5.  What are the fundamental standards for education activities?

E.  Adoption of Position Statements

1.  Purpose

2.  What typically initiates writing such a statement?

3.  Conditions to meet before a Position Statement is adopted

F.  Public Statements, Partnerships, and Alliances

1.  Purpose

2.  Why might we work with a non-UUFF organization?  

3. Examples

4.  What would we expect of an organization that we work with?

5.  When can Position Statements be made public?

6.  Does the Position Statement have to be quoted exactly?

7.  Can the SJC take public action in only its own name?  No

Appendix  

Project Proposal Form

Mission Statement & Goals & Objectives of SJC

Relevant policy statement of Board of Trustees

I.  Background and Introduction

A.  Scope   The Policy and Procedure Guidelines apply only to organized activities within the Fellowship that apply UUA principles to changing public perception or practices regarding social problems or that draw on Fellowship resources.  It primarily is a guide for the SJC, but it also impacts the social justice activities of the Board of Trustees and of Fellowship members. These guidelines apply whenever any member seeks SJC or Fellowship involvement ranging from use of Fellowship space or internal communication media to monetary or public support of a position. This document does not address the many individual activities of UUFF members that are undertaken independently and without public reference to the UUFF or the SJC, and without use of UUFF resources.  

B. Purpose and Vision

Material in each section assumes the application of relevant material in other sections as well.  Leaders of social justice activities need to be familiar with the entire document.  The Table of Contents provides a quick reference to related issues.            

 return to T.O.C.

 II.               Impromptu Activities

 A. Scope and purpose

This section addresses only those social justice activities by Fellowship members that are limited in scope to educational presentations or to advocacy of a very general nature that provides witness to a Unitarian Universalist principle.  These activities usually occur across only a few months.  This is in contrast to the activities described in the following sections that involve more extensive education and the possible adoption of a position statement by the Fellowship.  The purpose of this section is to

     1.     Promote internal collaborations and valuable informational activities.

     2.     Encourage those who make information available to also offer information for follow-up activities

     3.     Facilitate involvement of the public without inappropriate conflict or appearance of UUFF endorsements (either implied or explicit).

B.  Finding members with similar social issue interests

Ask someone on the SJC about this.  They may be able to provide names of people  and to share their own experience.  They can more easily identify any existing position statements already adopted by the Committee or the Fellowship that may relate to a specific interest.  They can advise the individual of any timing considerations and additional contacts that are needed, for example, to reserve space in the Fellowship or to publicize an interest or event.

C.  Responsibility of the SJC when an individual or informal group wants to produce an educational event independently

In such cases, the only responsibilities of the SJC are 

1. To correct the record if it discovers that its sponsorship, formal participation, or endorsement have been incorrectly publicized; and

2. To remind the congregation diplomatically, when necessary, that such independent activities do not necessarily involve the accurate and balanced research and open opportunities for participation that are the standard of SJC activities.

return to T.O.C

III. Priority Projects

A. Purpose of this process

     1.     To guide the identification of the most appropriate focused activities for the SJC and Fellowship.
     2.     To identify priorities.

B.  What are “Priority” and “Interim” Projects and reasons to have them

The smaller the size of the UUFF membership, the fewer separate issues or projects it will be capable of handling well.  There needs to be a deliberate process to decide what proposals to undertake in order to lessen the risk of energies being spread so broadly that burn-out, unreliable research and education, and misdirected action result.  There are two categories of projects.

A Priority Project is defined as the new major topic on which the Committee focuses study, education, and advocacy, for one to two years (July through June).   Generally, the selection of a Priority Project will reflect the results of a general membership survey  (see Section II, G) conducted within the past two or three years, depending on how much membership has changed or grown during that time.

An Interim Project is likely to be in response to an issue in the media and usually involves a reactivation of a Priority Project of an earlier year.  It receives less Committee energy and is usually of only a few months duration.  It may not have been a high priority on the general membership survey, but has strong support from at least a few Fellowship members.

return to T.O.C

C. Project Selection

  1. Ways to initiate a project proposal. Any member in good standing may submit a proposal to the SJC chairperson or designated alternate.  A Proposal Form (see Appendix) contains the information that the SJC would need to consider and that the proponent is asked to provide. If the proposal calls for relatively little investment of resources and on an issue previously studied or adopted, the new proposal may be extremely brief.  The proposal form and process that follow are intended to provide several benefits including assurance that:

A proposal receives full and fair consideration and with minimal confusion.

All major considerations of a proposal are at least identified, and, if possible, addressed.

Collaboration of individuals with related or similar interests and goals, both within and outside the UUFF, as appropriate.

Copies of the Proposal Form should be available from the Fellowship or SJC web site, the SJC chairperson, or the Fellowship office.  

       2. Steps for handling written proposals to the SJC

Proposer obtains the form, completes it, preferably electronically, otherwise as hard copy, and forwards it to the SJC Chairperson.

Proposer calls the SJC Chair to arrange to put the proposal on the SJC agenda.  As always, any member is welcome to attend Committee meetings. Proponent may also want to have other supporters attend the Committee meeting. 

The SJC considers the proposal, makes a determination, and responds promptly in writing to the Proponent with the results, reasons for decisions, date, and signature.

3. General criteria to apply to the proposal

Relevance.  Relates directly to a UU principle and, preferably, to a topic that emerged on a Membership interest survey (see G. below).

Timeliness.  Considers prevailing concerns and windows of opportunity for positive action and change.

Appeal to general membership:  Members have been specifically exposed to the issue and several have indicated intent to actively participate.

Practicality.  Should be able to produce identifiable change in public perceptions, policy, programs, or actions.  A proposal needs to lend itself to future action in order to be appropriate for SJC rather than for another group.

Leadership.  An enthusiastic leader, champion or coordinator has been identified (sometimes all 3 are needed).

4. Possible Committee determinations or outcomes

a     Adopt as an Interim or Priority Project in the current or following year.

b.    Adopt with conditions or contingencies listed, most typically that:

           (1.).     The project will succeed in obtaining sufficient funding or volunteer/leadership support beyond what has already been identified; or

           (2.).     Another committee that would be impacted and that has not yet formally supported the proposal, does so.

c.    Table, pending specified activities or information.  Most typically, this will be to obtain more consideration and feedback by the broader membership, especially on a controversial issue.  Usually this will happen only when the SJC concludes that the proposal has great merit and significant support already.  This response should list specific concerns or recommendations for consideration or completion.  

d.     Reject for the present with identification of main reason(s).

return to T.O.C

5.  Conducting a general membership interest survey

a.     Offer sample topics and solicit others at an announced promotional special meeting.

b.     Include in the written survey no more than a dozen possibilities that appear to meet the selection criteria above; ensure that the possibilities represent varied fields of interest.

c..     Provide a range of response options to each topic such as the following:
               a.     I would be very actively involved in work on this issue.
               b.     I would provide occasional support for or work on this.
               c.     I have some interest in this.
               d.     I have no interest in this.
               e.     I'd feel like actively objecting if this is selected.

 d.     Keep it short, preferably a single sheet.  Specifiy where the survey should be returned and by a date certain, in order to be included in tallies.

e.   Distribute a copy to each member in a considered cost-effective way.  An email or tri-fold "self-mailer" may help in an alphabetized "on-call" box at each service up until mailing is required to meet the return deadline.    

            f.     Review, tabulate, analyze and report the results in the earliest newsletter possible.

return to T.O.C

D.  Guidelines for Research and Education

1.  Purpose

This section is intended to ensure that information used by the Committee for its deliberations and for sharing with others in the UUFF and beyond is as accurate, balanced, constructive, and pragmatic as reasonably possible. Standards also ensure that the congregational members will not be asked to take a position on an issue unless the Social Justice Committee has already provided appropriate information, as described below, and with sufficient lead time to permit meaningful discussion and reflection.

2.  How much research and education are required for a topic?

It is appropriate that a sufficient amount of research and education is needed for the following situations, in approximately the order listed below:

     *     An update on an issue studied and acted on fairly recently.

     *     An update on an issue that has not been addressed for a year or two.

     *     A new topic that is not very controversial nor pivotal to many people.

     *     A new topic that is controversial and/or affects relatively great numbers of people in major ways.

Generally, at the lightest end of the issue spectrum, a written handout of relevant information is expected.  

At the most controversial and intellectually demanding end, a suggested minimum is that the UUFF members receive background information across at least three consecutive months using a variety of formats and methodologies.

3  What Are the SJC's General Research Standards?

The standards below apply to information provided to the committee for its consideration or provided by committee members.

Actively gather, research and consider diverse resources from multiple, contrasting perspectives.  Multiple resources are needed to corroborate each perspective.

 Emphasize the use of generally respected resources such as the following:

Relatively well-known and well-respected resources such as C-Span, Christian Science Monitor, the Wall Street Journal, the Washington Post, the New York Times, and National Geographic.

Original sources such as those who are working in the given field

UUA Social Justice website, if the topic is addressed.

Academic sources, both near and far

Think tank organizations, from contrasting perspectives

     Researchers are specifically identified for specific tasks and are prepared to be identified with their report.

4.  What education methodologies will be used?

Remember, the ultimate purpose of this committee is to use education to produce or prompt change. The following are examples of materials and activities that have been used to educate UUFF members and the greater community:

Printed and emailed materials- Within the congregation, this often includes newsletter articles, handout tables at Sunday services or other events.

Panel presentations and forums- When feedback is sought exclusively from the fellowship, the public may not be invited, but may generally be expected to attend as these are open.

Letters to editors, elected officials, and other opinion.leaders-When those letters are attributed to the Social Justice Committee, the Board, or the UUFF.

Peaceful demonstrations, usually at sites and times selected for their audiences or symbolism.

5.  What are the committee's fundamental standards for education?

Accuracy.  Information is to emphasize documented facts and original sources and to clearly distinguish such information from speculation and opinion.  To document something in this context means that the source can be specifically attributed and produced.

Constructive content.  Even though educational materials often will try to engage audiences that may be only casually interested initially, our standard is to never use purely sensational material or material that lacks respect and dignity for others. 

Brevity.  Generally we focus on main points of information and substantiation while identifying sources for additional information for those that want it.

return to T.O.C

E. Adoption of Position Statements

1.  Purpose  The purpose of officially adopting a Position Statements is to:

Identify statements of positions on social issues that fairly represent either the Committee, Board, or Fellowship to which they become attributed.

Identify the degree of support that is needed for such a position statement.

Ensure that those voting have had an adequate opportunity to prepare for the vote.

2.  What typically initiates the crafting of such a statement?

It is a natural outgrowth of prior Committee or Fellowship research, study, and discussion; or

The initiators want to draw on past study and consensus and apply it to a new related development in the public sector.

3.  Conditions to Meet Before a Position Statement is Adopted

The person proposing must be a member in good standing to make the proposal.

 Research and member education related to the position statement must comply with preceding sections.

The SJC must recommend the position statement to the full Fellowship by a vote that meets the conditions below:

1.  SJC members must be notified in writing electronically or otherwise of the meeting time and place of the vote, and of the draft text of the proposed position statement.  When possible, this meeting will be at a regularly scheduled time and

2.  SJC members will be notified no less than two weeks prior to their vote.  

3.   A super-majority 80% of participating UUFF SJC members must approve.

4.  Members may vote in absentia via email or hard copy delivered to a designated person or location within 24 hours after the scheduled meeting vote.

For a vote by the UUFF membership, the members must be notified in writing electronically or otherwise of the time, date, and any meeting place of the vote, and of the text of the statement under consideration.  Notification must be at least one month before the vote.  If the Annual Meeting is due within three months of the decision to call for a vote, then it is recommended that the vote should be as part that meeting.   Other aspects of the vote shall be the same as for votes at Annual Meetings.  

return to T.O.C

F.   F. Public Statements, Partnerships and Collaborations
P

1.  Purpose of adopted public statements and building collaborations is to:

Clearly outline the criteria that should be met before any UUFF resources or support are provided to a non-UUFF organization or cause.

Ensure that statements made to an audience outside the UUFF and claiming to represent the views of the SJC, the Board, or the general Fellowship, are accurate and authorized.

Ensure that public statements are correctly attributed.

Outline the process of approving a modification of a previously-adopted statement.

2.  Why might we work with a non-UUFF organization?  Examples?

Usually, it would be because they are supporting a change in society that we also wish to support, and we wish to utilize the synergies of collaboration and resources.  Here are examples.

 Adding our name to a list of supporters of another organization or position statement.

 Having a UUFF-Identified presence at a public event.

 Providing any UUFF resources--ranging from meeting space to our internal  communications to money or In-kind support--to an outside group.

 Publicly endorsing the organization with regard to mutual interests.

3. What would we expect of an organization that we work with?

Some brief homework should be done to establish that the organization...

 Is generally well respected.

 Is not known to have acted contrary to any UUAA principles.

 It is not for profit.

 That its website or printed materials Indicate a mission statement and activities to date that are compatible with UUFF.

4. When can public position statements be made?
The fundamental requirement is that the Fellowship has voted in favor of the position statement and in conformance with these Guidelines.  If the position was adopted more than two years earlier, then someone should conduct brief research to ensure that the statement is still accurate and valid.

Publicizing the position statement may be initiated by any member and may be accomplished by the vote and under the signature of the SJC or the Board on behalf of the Fellowship.

5. Does the position statement have to be quoted exactly?  
Generally, yes.  However it can be quoted within a letter or more lengthy statement that can give it more customized relevance to the selected issue. at hand. If it is to be slightly modified, perhaps to change an emphasis or give a specific example, then the change should be approved by the President or most senior officer available.

6.  Can the Social Justice Committee take public action in only its own name?
The Committee may sponsor public activities intended to provide education or witness of UU principles.  But activities that might be taken to the public that convey a more specific position statement must have Fellowship endorsement in accordance with these Guidelines.

return to T.O.C

Proposal to UUFF Social Justice Committee
(Please keep the completed form to no more than 2 pages.)

 Date Proposed:_____________________                          SJC Ref # ____________

Committee and Contact, or Member making the proposal
   Name____________________   Phone_______________  Email_______________

1.  Proposed topic or activity:




2.  For whom is this proposed topic or activity most important and how?




3.  Why is this a good time for this issue?



4.  What are your proposed activities for research, education, and possible action and what supporters, if any, have you identified who will be responsible for them?




5.  What identifiable change in public perceptions, policy, programs, or actions might this realistically produce (at UUFF, locally, regionally, state-wide, etc.)?



6.  Description of known relevant perspectives and values of UUFF member, including diversity.


7.  List of Attached Supporting Material, as available

___Very rough budget of expected expenses and where the funds would come from

___Copies of supporting articles, letters to editors, issue analyses

___Resources, alliances, or other resources potentially or currently being tapped

___Other (please identify)


 

Mission and Goals of UUFF Social Justice Committee

Mission Statement

To promote Unitarian Universalist principles of Social Justice in public affairs through education and advocacy in our fellowship and in the greater community.

      Goals 

1.   Promote the involvement of as many Fellowship and community members as possible in the above mission.

2.   Generally, link education to advocacy action.

3.   Apply the democratic process to selection of issues and the identification of positions taken by the Committee or, possibly, by the congregation.

4.   Provide members an opportunity to be reasonably informed about issues undertaken by the Committee and of reasons for positions adopted by the Committee.

5.   Ensure that information on issues that is brought to this committee, Fellowship members, or the public will be accurate and based on consideration of diverse and widely respected resources.

6.  As positions are adopted by the committee or Fellowship, consider collaboration with other organizations as part of a plan of advocacy.

Adopted by Social Justice Sub-Committee, February 2006

     Policy of the UUFF Board of Trustees

Any action taken by any member of the Fellowship which implies an endorsement by the fellowship of a particular position must have the consent of the Board of Trustees, and if the Board deems it appropriate, the consent of the membership of the congregation.

     Adopted December 8, 2005